Vodafone Plc’s Indian operations turned cash positive in the last quarter; however the joy was short lived because of the various bad experiences that the company has had in India.
In its ensuing battle against the Income Tax Department, the Bombay High Court verdict was against the company which brings the count to three times, that an Indian court has rules against the company.
An analyst who did not want to be named said “The matter has not been decided in finality as of date. But if Vodafone has to pay this kind of a tax, it will definitely be a huge setback”.
Due to rate pressures and competition in India, Vodafone has had to face bigger setbacks. The Indian operations were written down by the British major by Rs 15,156 crore.
The changes in the business conditions in India are what have prompted the company to decrease its asset value. These changes have been taking pace ever since the company acquired 67 per cent stake in Hutch Essar for $11.2 billion.
Due to the entry of six new telecom operators in India, all the major telecom companies have suffered as the new players have been reducing rates in a bid to get more market share. The rates war has led to margin cut for all telecom operators.
Sanjay Chawla, a research analyst at Anand Rathi has said “So far, it has not been turned out to be a great investment for Vodafone Plc. It seems that Hutch made a very smart move when they sold in the peak and since then valuations and market cap has only gone down”.
Vodafone has also paid Rs11,617 crore to acquire licenses in 9 circles for the 3G spectrum.
This would offer the company an edge over its competitors; however this would also increase interest costs and thus not allow for a quicker turnaround.
As 2G capex investments were low the telecom operators were cash positive, according to analysts however this would not be possible with the 3G investments.
Even though the outflow from the parent company has increased in value the profitability has clearly reduced. Hiking the value of put option by Rs 3,400 crore which is available to Essar. Essar has a 33 per cent stake in the Indian joint venture.
During the time of acquisition the agreement signed with Essar state that if Essar decided to sell its shares to Vodafone, the valuation of the shares would be appraised based on fir market price.

